There are no rules for vocal quality. You can't make them because the concept is so incredibly vague. It's a bit like literature, in that you can describe qualities that you like or dislike about someone's voice but you can't say definitively whether it's good or bad, not only because "good" and "bad" are incredibly subjective terms, but because one particular vocal quality may work just as well as another for a work, even if that quality is unusual or different.
The only way you can "objectively" say someone is a bad singer would be if they couldn't sing in a certain style. If you're trying to argue that Dylan would make a bad opera singer, obviously he would be. But he makes a great folk singer.
0 comments:
Post a Comment